Knowbotic
Plant systemsMCQ · 2 marks

Two identical young papaya plants, P and Q, grew side by side. A storm snapped off the top of each stem. P's stem broke below all its leaves, leaving a bare stump. Q's stem broke above its three lowest leaves, which stayed on. Both were watered. Q later grew new shoots, but P did not and slowly died. Which best explains this?

  1. Q's lower leaves could still make food, which was carried to the rest of the plant; P had no leaves left, so it used up its stored food.
  2. Q's lower leaves took in water from the air for the roots, but P's roots got no water.
  3. P's water-carrying tubes were cut, but Q's were not.
  4. P's roots could no longer take in food from the soil without the top of the stem.
Need a hint?

Both plants still had roots in wet soil. What could Q's plant do that P's bare stump could not?

The answer, explained

  1. Both plants still had roots that could take in water from the wet soil.
  2. Only Q still had leaves, so only Q could make food.
  3. P could not make food, so once its stored food was used up it died.
Answer (1): Q's lower leaves could still make food, which was carried to the rest of the plant; P had no leaves left, so it used up its stored food.

The mistake this question tests

Habit

Said what happened, not why

Both stems were snapped, so both had their tubes broken at the top; the roots of both could still take in water. Roots never take in food. The difference is leaves: Q's three leaves could still make food, carried in the food-carrying tubes to its roots and new shoots. P had to live on stored food until it ran out.

Wrong answers children often give:

  • Q's lower leaves took in water from the air for the roots, but P's roots got no water. Parts and their jobs (plants and body)
  • P's water-carrying tubes were cut, but Q's were not. Parts and their jobs (plants and body)
  • P's roots could no longer take in food from the soil without the top of the stem. Parts and their jobs (plants and body)

More PSLE Science plant systems questions

All free plant systems questions →

Practise PSLE Science until the mistakes stop.

Three PSLE questions, free, no sign-up. You’ll see exactly where the marks went. Then 7 days of everything for S$4.99.