Knowbotic
Plant systemsOpen-ended · 4 marks

Jun grew two identical lettuce seedlings with their roots in jars of the same water with mineral salts dissolved in it. Both jars were in the same sunny place. In jar A, a small pump bubbled air through the water all the time. Jar B had no pump, and very little air was left in its water after a few days. After 3 weeks, the lettuce in jar A had grown well, with white, healthy roots. The lettuce in jar B was small, with brown, rotting roots.

  1. What was Jun trying to find out? [1]
  2. Explain why the lettuce in jar B grew poorly. [2]
  3. Name one thing, other than the place, that Jun kept the same for both jars. [1]
Need a hint?

(b) Roots are alive. What do all living things need that jar B's water was short of?

Model answer

  1. (a) Only the pump (air in the water) was different, and growth was compared.
  2. (b) Roots need air to stay alive and healthy; jar B's roots had too little, so they rotted.
  3. (b) Rotting roots take in less water and mineral salts, so the lettuce grew poorly.
  4. (c) Everything else, such as the kind of seedling and the water with mineral salts, was kept the same.

(a) Whether bubbling air through the water (air in the water round the roots) affects how well lettuce grows.

(b) Roots are living parts and need air. With very little air in the water, the roots in jar B were damaged and began to rot, so they took in less water and mineral salts, and the lettuce grew poorly.

(c) The kind and size of the seedling (also accepted: the amount of water; the amount of mineral salts; the size of the jar).

How the 4 marks are given

  • (a) States the aim: whether air in the water round the roots affects the growth of the lettuce.
  • (b) States that roots are living and need air, and jar B's water had very little air.
  • (b) States that the damaged roots took in less water and mineral salts, so the lettuce grew poorly.
  • (c) Names one constant: kind / size of seedling, amount of water, amount of mineral salts, size of jar.

One mark for each point. Keywords count: an everyday word in place of the science word can lose the mark.

The mistake this question tests

Habit

Said what happened, not why

"Jar B had less water" is wrong: both jars had the same water. What differed was the air in the water. Roots are living parts and need air; without it they rot, and rotting roots take in less water and mineral salts.

More PSLE Science plant systems questions

All free plant systems questions →

Practise PSLE Science until the mistakes stop.

Three PSLE questions, free, no sign-up. You’ll see exactly where the marks went. Then 7 days of everything for S$4.99.