Plants lose water through their leaves faster when the air is warmer, and faster in bright light than in dim light.Kai wanted to find out whether air temperature affects how much water a potted pepper plant loses. He covered the soil of two identical potted pepper plants with plastic, so that water could leave only through the plants. He put plant X in a warm, dark storeroom at 32 °C and plant Y on a cool, bright windowsill at 24 °C. After 6 hours, each pot had lost 18 g. Kai concluded that air temperature does not affect water loss.Why is his conclusion not safe, and what should he change?
- It is safe: both plants lost 18 g, so temperature made no difference.
- He should keep the amount of light the same, because the darkness may have slowed plant X's water loss as much as the warmth sped it up.
- He should give plant X more leaves, so that it can lose water faster in the storeroom.
- He should keep the temperature the same in both places, because temperature should never be changed in a fair test.
Need a hint?
Read where each plant was kept, and describe both places fully.
The answer, explained
- Plant X had warmer air (more loss) but darkness (less loss).
- Plant Y had cooler air (less loss) but bright light (more loss).
- The two differences can cancel out, giving the same 18 g.
- Keep the light the same and compare again.
The mistake this question tests
Fair test: what changes, what stays the same
Equal losses do not show that temperature has no effect. Plant X was warmer, which speeds up water loss, but also in the dark, which slows it down, so the two effects can cancel out. Only the changed variable, temperature, should differ; the light must be kept the same.
Wrong answers children often give:
- It is safe: both plants lost 18 g, so temperature made no difference. Concluded more than the results show
- He should give plant X more leaves, so that it can lose water faster in the storeroom. Fair test: what changes, what stays the same
- He should keep the temperature the same in both places, because temperature should never be changed in a fair test. Fair test: what changes, what stays the same
More PSLE Science plant systems questions
Water-storing crystals soak up water and swell into a jelly
See the answer →Open-ended · 4mRavi wanted to find out whether roots help to hold a plant in the soil
See the answer →MCQ · 2mRaju planted identical long bean seedlings in a crowded garden bed, among taller plants that shade the ground
See the answer →MCQ · 2mMrs Wong bought some cut roses and put them in a vase of water
See the answer →MCQ · 2mA gardener noticed that the leaves of a creeping sea morning glory on a beach stay fresh even on very hot…
See the answer →MCQ · 2mKen dipped the cut ends of 10 bougainvillea stem cuttings in a rooting powder and planted them in moist sand
See the answer →Practise PSLE Science until the mistakes stop.
Three PSLE questions, free, no sign-up. You’ll see exactly where the marks went. Then 7 days of everything for S$4.99.