Ravi wanted to find out whether roots help to hold a plant in the soil. He used two identical potted maize seedlings, X and Y. He cut off most of the roots of seedling Y, then replanted both in the same kind of soil. He then blew air at both with a fan on the same setting from the same distance.
- Which variable did Ravi change? [1]
- Seedling Y fell over first. What does this result show about roots? [1]
- Give one variable he kept the same, and say why. [1]
- Ravi tested only one pair of seedlings. How could he make his results more reliable? [1]
Need a hint?
(c) If seedling Y were closer to the fan, could you tell whether it fell because of its roots?
Model answer
- (a) Only the roots were changed: Y had most of its roots cut off.
- (b) Y, with fewer roots, fell first: roots hold the plant firmly.
- (c), (d) Keep the fan, distance and soil the same; repeat with more seedlings.
(a) The amount of roots (whether most of the roots were cut off).
(b) Roots help to hold a plant firmly in the soil.
(c) The fan setting (or distance from the fan, or kind of soil, or size of seedling), so that only the amount of roots affected whether the seedling fell over.
(d) Repeat the test with more pairs of seedlings and see if the seedling with fewer roots falls first each time.
How the 4 marks are given
- (a) Names the amount of roots / whether the roots were cut off.
- (b) States that roots help hold the plant firmly in the soil.
- (c) Names one variable kept the same (fan setting, distance, kind of soil, size of seedling) and says so that only the roots affected the result / for a fair test.
- (d) States that he should repeat with more (pairs of) seedlings.
One mark for each point. Keywords count: an everyday word in place of the science word can lose the mark.
The mistake this question tests
Fair test: what changes, what stays the same
For (c), naming a variable is not enough: say why it is kept the same, so that only the roots can explain which seedling fell first. For (d), more seedlings make the result more reliable.
More PSLE Science plant systems questions
Plants lose water through their leaves faster when the air is warmer, and faster in bright light than in dim…
See the answer →Open-ended · 3mWater-storing crystals soak up water and swell into a jelly
See the answer →MCQ · 2mRaju planted identical long bean seedlings in a crowded garden bed, among taller plants that shade the ground
See the answer →MCQ · 2mMrs Wong bought some cut roses and put them in a vase of water
See the answer →MCQ · 2mA gardener noticed that the leaves of a creeping sea morning glory on a beach stay fresh even on very hot…
See the answer →MCQ · 2mKen dipped the cut ends of 10 bougainvillea stem cuttings in a rooting powder and planted them in moist sand
See the answer →Practise PSLE Science until the mistakes stop.
Three PSLE questions, free, no sign-up. You’ll see exactly where the marks went. Then 7 days of everything for S$4.99.