Ken dipped the cut ends of 10 bougainvillea stem cuttings in a rooting powder and planted them in moist sand. After 4 weeks, 9 of them had grown roots. He concluded: "The rooting powder makes bougainvillea cuttings grow roots."Why can he not be sure of this?
- One cutting did not grow roots, so the powder does not work at all.
- He should have used fewer cuttings, so that he could look after each one better.
- Roots can grow only from seeds, so the powder must have made all of the roots.
- He did not plant any cuttings without the powder, so he cannot tell whether they would have grown roots anyway.
Need a hint?
Suppose a friend says the cuttings would have grown roots without the powder. Can Ken's results show the friend is wrong?
The answer, explained
- All 10 cuttings had the powder.
- Ken has no cuttings without the powder to compare with.
- So he cannot tell whether the powder made any difference.
The mistake this question tests
Concluded more than the results show
Nine out of ten cuttings growing roots sounds good, but stem cuttings of many plants grow roots on their own. Without a control, cuttings set up the same way but with no powder, there is nothing to compare with.
Wrong answers children often give:
- One cutting did not grow roots, so the powder does not work at all. Concluded more than the results show
- He should have used fewer cuttings, so that he could look after each one better. Fair test: what changes, what stays the same
- Roots can grow only from seeds, so the powder must have made all of the roots. Stopped before the full cause and effect
More PSLE Science plant systems questions
Ana claims: "Plants take in most of their water through their leaves." Which observation shows that her claim…
See the answer →Open-ended · 3mAli wanted to find out whether grass with long roots holds soil in place better than grass with short roots
See the answer →MCQ · 2mMrs Wong bought some cut roses and put them in a vase of water
See the answer →MCQ · 2mPlants lose water through their leaves faster when the air is warmer, and faster in bright light than in dim…
See the answer →MCQ · 2mA gardener noticed that the leaves of a creeping sea morning glory on a beach stay fresh even on very hot…
See the answer →MCQ · 2mTwo identical potted plants of the same kind were watered with the same amount every day
See the answer →Practise PSLE Science until the mistakes stop.
Three PSLE questions, free, no sign-up. You’ll see exactly where the marks went. Then 7 days of everything for S$4.99.