Knowbotic
Plant systemsOpen-ended · 3 marks

Ali wanted to find out whether grass with long roots holds soil in place better than grass with short roots. He grew grass P, which has long roots, in one tray of soil and grass Q, which has short roots, in another tray of the same soil. He tilted both trays to the same slope and poured 2 litres of water down each one. He collected the soil that was washed off: 40 g from tray P and 55 g from tray Q.

  1. Which job of roots was Ali testing? [1]
  2. Ali concluded that long roots hold soil better. Why is it not reliable to decide this from one tray of each grass? [1]
  3. Suggest how Ali could make his result more reliable. [1]
Need a hint?

(b) If Ali repeated the test with two new trays, would he get exactly 40 g and 55 g again?

Model answer

  1. (a) Roots grip the soil and hold the plant firmly.
  2. (b) One tray of each may differ by chance in how it was packed or watered.
  3. (c) Use many trays of each grass and compare the averages.

(a) Roots hold the plant firmly in the soil (they hold the soil together).

(b) One tray could give a different result by chance, for example because its soil was packed more firmly or the water was poured a little differently, so with one tray each the 15 g difference may not be caused by the roots.

(c) Set up several trays of each grass, for example five of P and five of Q, the same way, and compare the average mass of soil washed off.

How the 3 marks are given

  • (a) States that roots hold the plant firmly in the soil / hold the soil in place.
  • (b) States that one tray of each could differ by chance (e.g. soil packed differently), so the difference may not be due to the roots.
  • (c) Suggests using more trays of each grass (or repeating the test) and comparing the averages.

One mark for each point. Keywords count: an everyday word in place of the science word can lose the mark.

The mistake this question tests

Habit

Concluded more than the results show

"Do it again" alone is not enough for (c): say what to repeat: more trays of each grass, set up the same way, then compare the average soil lost. One tray each cannot tell a real difference from a chance one.

More PSLE Science plant systems questions

All free plant systems questions →

Practise PSLE Science until the mistakes stop.

Three PSLE questions, free, no sign-up. You’ll see exactly where the marks went. Then 7 days of everything for S$4.99.