Two identical vacuum flasks, P and Q, were set up in the same room. Flask P held 30 live crickets. Flask Q held small pebbles of the same total mass. The crickets, the pebbles and the air in both flasks were at room temperature at the start. Each flask was closed with a stopper holding a thermometer, with air left inside. After 2 hours, the thermometer in P read 2 °C higher than at the start, and the one in Q had not changed.Which best explains the result?
- The crickets used up some oxygen, and air with less oxygen is warmer.
- The crickets were warmer than the pebbles at the start, and their warmth spread into the air.
- The carbon dioxide the crickets breathed out is a hot gas, so it warmed the flask.
- The crickets released energy from their food, and some of it was given off as heat.
Need a hint?
Flask Q tells you the room did not warm the flasks. What do living things do with the food and oxygen they take in?
The answer, explained
- Flask Q, with pebbles, did not warm up, so the room or the flask itself did not cause the rise.
- The live crickets use oxygen to release energy from their food.
- Some of this energy is given off as heat, which the vacuum flask keeps in, so P's temperature rose.
The mistake this question tests
Energy conversion chains
Everything started at room temperature, so the crickets were not warmer to begin with, and flask Q shows the room did not heat the flasks. Less oxygen does not warm air, and breathed-out carbon dioxide is not hot in itself. Living things use oxygen to release energy from food, and some of that energy is given off as heat; the vacuum flask kept it in.
Wrong answers children often give:
- The crickets used up some oxygen, and air with less oxygen is warmer. Said what happened, not why
- The crickets were warmer than the pebbles at the start, and their warmth spread into the air. Heat and temperature
- The carbon dioxide the crickets breathed out is a hot gas, so it warmed the flask. Said what happened, not why
More PSLE Science human systems questions
Wei claims: "Food is digested only in the stomach." Which observation shows that his claim is wrong?
See the answer →MCQ · 2mA python swallows a rat whole, without chewing it
See the answer →Open-ended · 2mWhen a person vomits soon after a meal, food comes back up the gullet and out of the mouth
See the answer →MCQ · 2mKumar pushed a ping-pong ball into one end of a long, stretchy tube made of cloth
See the answer →MCQ · 2mLimewater turns chalky when carbon dioxide passes through it
See the answer →Open-ended · 3mOn one day, Mr Goh ate and drank 2.5 kg of food and drinks, and his digestive system was healthy
See the answer →Practise PSLE Science until the mistakes stop.
Three PSLE questions, free, no sign-up. You’ll see exactly where the marks went. Then 7 days of everything for S$4.99.