Limewater turns chalky when carbon dioxide passes through it. Tom sat still and breathed out 1 litre of air through a tube of limewater, and timed how long it took to turn chalky. After resting, he held his breath for 30 seconds, then breathed out 1 litre through a fresh tube of the same limewater. This time it turned chalky much sooner.Which explains this?
- While he held his breath, his cells stopped making carbon dioxide.
- While he held his breath, his lungs turned the oxygen in them into carbon dioxide.
- Holding his breath made the air he breathed out warmer, and warm air turns limewater chalky faster.
- While he held his breath, his blood kept bringing carbon dioxide to his lungs, but none of it was breathed out, so it built up there.
Need a hint?
His cells kept working during the 30 seconds. Where does the carbon dioxide they make go, and could it leave his body?
The answer, explained
- His cells kept releasing energy and making carbon dioxide.
- The blood carried it to the lungs, but he was not breathing out.
- So the air in his lungs gathered more carbon dioxide, and the limewater turned chalky sooner.
The mistake this question tests
Said what happened, not why
The cells do not stop making carbon dioxide when we stop breathing, and the lungs do not make it: the blood carries it to the lungs from the cells. With no air leaving for 30 seconds, it gathered in the lungs, so each litre breathed out held more of it.
Wrong answers children often give:
- While he held his breath, his cells stopped making carbon dioxide. Said what happened, not why
- While he held his breath, his lungs turned the oxygen in them into carbon dioxide. Parts and their jobs (plants and body)
- Holding his breath made the air he breathed out warmer, and warm air turns limewater chalky faster. Said what happened, not why
More PSLE Science human systems questions
A python swallows a rat whole, without chewing it
See the answer →Open-ended · 3mOn one day, Mr Goh ate and drank 2.5 kg of food and drinks, and his digestive system was healthy
See the answer →Open-ended · 3mJia put 5 live crickets on a wire mesh inside a sealed tube, A
See the answer →MCQ · 2mWei claims: "Food is digested only in the stomach." Which observation shows that his claim is wrong?
See the answer →Open-ended · 2mWhen a person vomits soon after a meal, food comes back up the gullet and out of the mouth
See the answer →MCQ · 2mKumar pushed a ping-pong ball into one end of a long, stretchy tube made of cloth
See the answer →Practise PSLE Science until the mistakes stop.
Three PSLE questions, free, no sign-up. You’ll see exactly where the marks went. Then 7 days of everything for S$4.99.