Knowbotic
Diversity & materialsOpen-ended · 4 marks

A trampoline has a fabric mat that people jump on. The mat is stretched across a metal frame and is kept outdoors.

  1. State two properties that the material of the mat must have, and explain why each is needed. [2]
  2. Ravi hung a strip of each of three fabrics, P, Q and R, from a hook and added 1 kg masses one at a time until the strip tore. Strip P tore at 12 kg, strip Q at 20 kg and strip R at 7 kg. The strip of fabric Q was twice as wide as the other two. Explain why Ravi cannot conclude that fabric Q is the strongest, and state one change he should make. [2]
Need a hint?

(b) Besides the kind of fabric, what else was different about strip Q?

Model answer

  1. (a) People land hard on the mat, so it must be strong and flexible.
  2. It stays outdoors, so it should also be waterproof.
  3. (b) Strip Q was wider, so two things changed; the strips must all be the same width.

(a) It must be strong, so that it does not tear when people jump on it; and flexible, so that it bends under the jumper and springs them up again. (It must also be waterproof, so that rain does not soak or rot it.)

(b) Strip Q was wider, so it may have held more mass because of its width, not because fabric Q is stronger. He should test strips of all three fabrics that are the same width (and the same length and thickness).

How the 4 marks are given

  • (a) States one property with its reason, e.g. strong, so it does not tear when people jump on it.
  • (a) States a second property with its reason, e.g. flexible, so it bends under the jumper / waterproof, because it is outdoors in the rain.
  • (b) States that strip Q was wider, so its width (not the kind of fabric) may have let it hold more mass.
  • (b) States that strips of the same width / size should be used for all three fabrics.

One mark for each point. Keywords count: an everyday word in place of the science word can lose the mark.

The mistake this question tests

Habit

Fair test: what changes, what stays the same

A strength test must change only the fabric. Strip Q was twice as wide, so it could hold more mass for that reason alone. The strips must be the same size before the fabrics can be compared.

More PSLE Science diversity & materials questions

All free diversity & materials questions →

Practise PSLE Science until the mistakes stop.

Three PSLE questions, free, no sign-up. You’ll see exactly where the marks went. Then 7 days of everything for S$4.99.