Knowbotic
Diversity & materialsOpen-ended · 4 marks

Ali put the same mass of fresh rambutans into three identical airtight jars and kept them side by side at 30 °C for 7 days.Jar P: with a packet that takes in oxygen from the air in the jarJar Q: with a packet of the same size that takes in carbon dioxide from the air in the jarJar R: with no packetAfter 7 days, there was no mould in jar P, and a lot of mould in jars Q and R.

  1. Using the results, what does mould need from the air to grow? [1]
  2. Why did Ali set up jar Q, instead of comparing only jars P and R? [1]
  3. On day 7, Ali opened jar P and left it open in the warm kitchen. The rambutans were still fresh and moist. Predict what would happen to them after a few days, and explain your prediction. [2]
Need a hint?

(b) In what ways is jar P different from jar R? Which jar helps you tell those apart?

Model answer

  1. (a) Mould grew in Q and R, which had oxygen, but not in P, whose oxygen was taken in.
  2. (b) Q has a packet like P but still has oxygen; mould grew, so a packet alone does not stop mould.
  3. (c) Once P is open, oxygen reaches the moist fruit, so mould would grow.

(a) Oxygen: the only jar with no mould was P, where the oxygen was taken in.

(b) Jar Q also had a packet but still had oxygen, and mould grew in it. This shows that it was taking away the oxygen, and not just having a packet in the jar, that stopped the mould in P.

(c) Mould would grow on the rambutans, because air with oxygen can now reach them (and mould spores from the kitchen air can land on them).

How the 4 marks are given

  • (a) States oxygen, as the only jar without mould was the one whose oxygen was taken in.
  • (b) States that Q shows a packet on its own (with oxygen still there) does not stop mould, so it was taking away the oxygen that stopped it in P.
  • (c) Predicts that mould would grow on the rambutans.
  • (c) Explains that air with oxygen can now reach the rambutans.

One mark for each point. Keywords count: an everyday word in place of the science word can lose the mark.

The mistake this question tests

Habit

Fair test: what changes, what stays the same

For (b), comparing P with R alone cannot show what stopped the mould, because P differs from R in two ways: it has a packet, and it has no oxygen. Jar Q has a packet but keeps its oxygen, and mould grew there, so the packet itself was not the cause.

More PSLE Science diversity & materials questions

All free diversity & materials questions →

Practise PSLE Science until the mistakes stop.

Three PSLE questions, free, no sign-up. You’ll see exactly where the marks went. Then 7 days of everything for S$4.99.