Salt dough conducts electricity; sugar dough does not. Ivy pressed the two wires from a battery into two separate lumps of salt dough, X and Y. She pushed one leg of a bulb into X and the other leg into Y, and the bulb lit. When she pressed X and Y together so that they touched, the bulb went out. When she pulled them apart again, it lit again.Why did the bulb go out, and how can she stop it happening when the lumps are close together?
- The salt in the dough was used up; she can add more salt to X and Y.
- The current took the path through the touching dough instead of through the bulb; she can put a piece of sugar dough between X and Y.
- Pressing the lumps together broke the bulb; she can use a new bulb.
- Touching lumps make the circuit open; she can put a piece of salt dough between X and Y.
Need a hint?
Trace the current from X to Y before the lumps touch, and after. What changed? Then use the first sentence of the question to judge each fix.
The answer, explained
- Salt dough is a conductor, so touching lumps make a path from X to Y with no bulb in it.
- The current takes this path and bypasses the bulb.
- An insulator, such as sugar dough, between the lumps stops them joining.
The mistake this question tests
Conductors and insulators
The bulb lit again when the lumps were pulled apart, so it was not broken. When X and Y touch, the salt dough itself joins them, giving the current an easy path that bypasses the bulb, so the bulb goes out. A piece of sugar dough, an insulator, keeps X and Y apart; salt dough between them would still join them.
Wrong answers children often give:
- The salt in the dough was used up; she can add more salt to X and Y. Closed circuits, series and parallel
- Pressing the lumps together broke the bulb; she can use a new bulb. Closed circuits, series and parallel
- Touching lumps make the circuit open; she can put a piece of salt dough between X and Y. Conductors and insulators
More PSLE Science electrical systems questions
Plastic is used for:
See the answer →Open-ended · 3mA sweet wrapper is made of a layer of aluminium foil stuck to a layer of paper
See the answer →MCQ · 2mThe number display above a hawker stall uses seven light bars for each digit
See the answer →MCQ · 2mA door alarm uses a switch made of two thin, springy strips sealed in a glass tube, with a small gap between…
See the answer →Open-ended · 3mJia is building a bedside light with one battery, one switch, S, and three identical bulbs
See the answer →Open-ended · 3mWen pushed a copper strip and a zinc strip into each of three lemons
See the answer →Practise PSLE Science until the mistakes stop.
Three PSLE questions, free, no sign-up. You’ll see exactly where the marks went. Then 7 days of everything for S$4.99.