Wen pushed a copper strip and a zinc strip into each of three lemons. A lemon with two different metals in it can act as a cell. He joined the three lemon cells in series with a small light, the copper strip of each lemon joined to the zinc strip of the next, and the light lit.
- Ali says, "The copper and zinc strips make the electricity on their own. The lemons are not needed." Describe a set-up Wen could use to test Ali's idea. [1]
- Wen now wants to find out whether the kind of fruit affects how brightly the light shines. He will use three oranges in place of the three lemons. Give two things he must keep the same. [2]
Need a hint?
(a) To test whether something is needed, what must the second set-up leave out, and what must it keep the same?
Model answer
- (a) Change only one thing: remove the lemons, keep the strips, wires and light the same.
- If the light does not light, the lemons are needed.
- (b) Only the kind of fruit should change; everything else that could affect the light stays the same.
(a) Use the same circuit, strips and light, but with the strips held apart in the same places without the lemons, for example pushed into a dry block of wood or held in the air. If the light does not light, the lemons are needed.
(b) Any two of: the same metals and the same size of strips; the same depth the strips are pushed in; the same distance between the two strips in each fruit; the same number of fruits; the same light; the same wires.
How the 3 marks are given
- (a) Describes the same set-up (same strips, light and circuit) but with no lemons, e.g. the strips held apart in air or in a dry block of wood.
- (b) Gives one correct variable to keep the same, e.g. same metals / size of strips.
- (b) Gives a second, different correct variable, e.g. same distance between the strips, same depth, same number of fruits, same light.
One mark for each point. Keywords count: an everyday word in place of the science word can lose the mark.
The mistake this question tests
Fair test: what changes, what stays the same
For (a), replacing the lemons with batteries does not test Ali's idea: batteries are already a source of electrical energy, so the light would light either way. The set-up must keep everything the same except the lemons, so that only the lemons are missing.
More PSLE Science electrical systems questions
Jun wants to find out which of two brands of torch bulb, P or Q, gives the brighter light
See the answer →MCQ · 2mOne wire in Ken's model windmill broke, so he replaced it with a strip cut from a shiny sweet tube
See the answer →MCQ · 2mThe number display above a hawker stall uses seven light bars for each digit
See the answer →MCQ · 2mA door alarm uses a switch made of two thin, springy strips sealed in a glass tube, with a small gap between…
See the answer →Open-ended · 3mJia is building a bedside light with one battery, one switch, S, and three identical bulbs
See the answer →MCQ · 2mPlastic is used for:
See the answer →Practise PSLE Science until the mistakes stop.
Three PSLE questions, free, no sign-up. You’ll see exactly where the marks went. Then 7 days of everything for S$4.99.