Ravi put 10 bean seeds on moist cotton wool in a dark cupboard (set-up A) and 10 bean seeds on dry cotton wool on a sunny windowsill (set-up B). After 5 days, the seeds in A had germinated and those in B had not. He concluded that seeds need water to germinate.Why is his experiment not a fair test of this?
- He used too few seeds, so his results are not reliable.
- Both water and light differed between A and B, so he cannot tell which one caused the result.
- Seeds need light to germinate, so the seeds in B should have germinated.
- The seeds in A germinated because darkness helps seeds to germinate.
Need a hint?
List everything that is different between A and B.
The answer, explained
- A and B differ in water (moist or dry) and in light (dark cupboard or sunny windowsill).
- With more than one variable changed, the result cannot be linked to water alone.
- A fair test would keep both set-ups in the same place and change only whether the cotton wool is moist.
Answer (2): Both water and light differed between A and B, so he cannot tell which one caused the result.
The mistake this question tests
Habit
Fair test: what changes, what stays the same
Seeds do not need light to germinate, and more seeds would only make the results more reliable. The problem is that A and B differ in both water and light, so this is not a fair test.
Wrong answers children often give:
- He used too few seeds, so his results are not reliable. Misread what the experiment tests
- Seeds need light to germinate, so the seeds in B should have germinated. Concluded more than the results show
- The seeds in A germinated because darkness helps seeds to germinate. Concluded more than the results show
More PSLE Science life cycles & reproduction questions
Open-ended · 3m
Ali filled two identical pots with the same soil
See the answer →Open-ended · 3mBefore it is born, a baby develops in its mother's womb
See the answer →MCQ · 2mA papaya fruit had 300 seeds inside it
See the answer →Open-ended · 2mBed bugs are insects with three stages: egg, nymph and adult
See the answer →MCQ · 2mWhich statement is true of the life cycles of all animals?
See the answer →MCQ · 2mA bean seed germinated on damp cotton wool
See the answer →Practise PSLE Science until the mistakes stop.
Three PSLE questions, free, no sign-up. You’ll see exactly where the marks went. Then 7 days of everything for S$4.99.