Knowbotic
Life cycles & reproductionOpen-ended · 3 marks

Ali filled two identical pots with the same soil. He pressed the soil in pot P down hard until it was tightly packed, and left the soil in pot Q loose. He sowed 20 seeds of the same kind in each pot and gave both pots the same amount of water. After a week, 5 seeds had germinated in pot P and 18 in pot Q.

  1. What was Ali trying to find out? [1]
  2. Suggest why fewer seeds germinated in the tightly packed soil. [1]
  3. Name one other thing Ali must keep the same for both pots. [1]
Need a hint?

(b) What is found between loose bits of soil, and what happens to it when the soil is pressed down hard?

Model answer

  1. (a) Only how tightly the soil was packed was changed.
  2. (b) Packing removes air spaces in the soil.
  3. Seeds need air to germinate, so fewer germinated in P.
  4. (c) Other conditions must match, such as temperature.

(a) Whether packing the soil tightly affects how many seeds germinate.

(b) Tightly packed soil has fewer and smaller air spaces, so the seeds got less air (oxygen), which they need to germinate.

(c) Any one of: where the pots were kept (temperature), the depth the seeds were sown, the kind of seeds, the time.

How the 3 marks are given

  • (a) States the aim: whether how tightly the soil is packed affects (the number of) seeds germinating.
  • (b) Suggests that packed soil has fewer air spaces, so the seeds got less air / oxygen.
  • (c) Names one valid constant, e.g. the temperature / place, the sowing depth, the kind of seeds.

One mark for each point. Keywords count: an everyday word in place of the science word can lose the mark.

The mistake this question tests

Habit

Fair test: what changes, what stays the same

For (b), "the soil is too hard" is not an explanation. Pressing the soil squeezes out the air spaces, so the seeds get less air, one of the conditions needed for germination.

More PSLE Science life cycles & reproduction questions

All free life cycles & reproduction questions →

Practise PSLE Science until the mistakes stop.

Three PSLE questions, free, no sign-up. You’ll see exactly where the marks went. Then 7 days of everything for S$4.99.