Knowbotic
Human systemsOpen-ended · 3 marks

A plastic bottle was filled with water and held upside down in a basin of water. Each pupil took a deep breath and breathed out through a tube into the bottle, as hard as possible, in one breath. The air pushed out some of the water. The volume of water pushed out was measured.

  1. What does the volume of water pushed out measure? [1]
  2. Why was the same bottle used for every pupil? [1]
  3. Two pupils who swim every day pushed out more water than two pupils who do not. Lin concludes that swimming makes everyone's lungs hold more air. Give one reason why this cannot be concluded. [1]
Need a hint?

(c) How many pupils were in each group? Could anything other than swimming make the difference?

Model answer

  1. (a) Air breathed out takes the place of water.
  2. (b) Same bottle, so results compare fairly.
  3. (c) Too few pupils, and other differences, so swimming may not be the cause.

(a) The volume of air that the pupil breathed out in one breath.

(b) So that the results can be compared fairly: the same measuring set-up for everyone.

(c) Only four pupils were tested, which is too few; also accepted: the pupils may differ in other ways, such as height or age.

How the 3 marks are given

  • (a) States the volume of air breathed out in one breath.
  • (b) States that it keeps the test fair / so only the pupil differs.
  • (c) States that too few pupils were tested / the pupils differ in other ways (e.g. size, age), so the difference may not be due to swimming.

One mark for each point. Keywords count: an everyday word in place of the science word can lose the mark.

The mistake this question tests

Habit

Concluded more than the results show

Four pupils cannot show what is true of everyone. The swimmers might also be taller or older. A conclusion needs many people, alike in every way except the one being tested.

More PSLE Science human systems questions

All free human systems questions →

Practise PSLE Science until the mistakes stop.

Three PSLE questions, free, no sign-up. You’ll see exactly where the marks went. Then 7 days of everything for S$4.99.