Knowbotic
Human systemsMCQ · 2 marks

Ming took the pulse of his sister at rest: 82 beats per minute. He took his own pulse at rest: 75 beats per minute. He concluded: "Girls have higher heart rates at rest than boys." Why is his conclusion not reliable?

  1. He should have measured their pulses after exercise, not at rest.
  2. He measured only one girl and one boy, so the difference could be for other reasons; he needs to measure many girls and boys.
  3. A pulse taken at the wrist does not show the heart rate.
  4. Boys' hearts beat more slowly because boys have bigger lungs.
Need a hint?

How many people did Ming test? Could two people differ for reasons that have nothing to do with being a girl or a boy?

The answer, explained

  1. Only two people were measured.
  2. Two people can differ for many reasons.
  3. Many girls and many boys must be measured before concluding.
Answer (2): He measured only one girl and one boy, so the difference could be for other reasons; he needs to measure many girls and boys.

The mistake this question tests

Habit

Concluded more than the results show

A pulse does show the heart rate, and resting is fine for his question. But one girl and one boy are not enough: they may differ because of age, fitness or many other things. To draw a conclusion about all girls and boys, he must measure many of each.

Wrong answers children often give:

  • He should have measured their pulses after exercise, not at rest. Fair test: what changes, what stays the same
  • A pulse taken at the wrist does not show the heart rate. Parts and their jobs (plants and body)
  • Boys' hearts beat more slowly because boys have bigger lungs. Concluded more than the results show

More PSLE Science human systems questions

All free human systems questions →

Practise PSLE Science until the mistakes stop.

Three PSLE questions, free, no sign-up. You’ll see exactly where the marks went. Then 7 days of everything for S$4.99.