Ming took the pulse of his sister at rest: 82 beats per minute. He took his own pulse at rest: 75 beats per minute. He concluded: "Girls have higher heart rates at rest than boys." Why is his conclusion not reliable?
- He should have measured their pulses after exercise, not at rest.
- He measured only one girl and one boy, so the difference could be for other reasons; he needs to measure many girls and boys.
- A pulse taken at the wrist does not show the heart rate.
- Boys' hearts beat more slowly because boys have bigger lungs.
Need a hint?
How many people did Ming test? Could two people differ for reasons that have nothing to do with being a girl or a boy?
The answer, explained
- Only two people were measured.
- Two people can differ for many reasons.
- Many girls and many boys must be measured before concluding.
The mistake this question tests
Concluded more than the results show
A pulse does show the heart rate, and resting is fine for his question. But one girl and one boy are not enough: they may differ because of age, fitness or many other things. To draw a conclusion about all girls and boys, he must measure many of each.
Wrong answers children often give:
- He should have measured their pulses after exercise, not at rest. Fair test: what changes, what stays the same
- A pulse taken at the wrist does not show the heart rate. Parts and their jobs (plants and body)
- Boys' hearts beat more slowly because boys have bigger lungs. Concluded more than the results show
More PSLE Science human systems questions
Wei claims: "Food is digested only in the stomach." Which observation shows that his claim is wrong?
See the answer →Open-ended · 3mA doctor gave Mr Tan a capsule of a harmless blue dye with his breakfast at 8 am on Monday
See the answer →Open-ended · 3mA plastic bottle was filled with water and held upside down in a basin of water
See the answer →MCQ · 2mA python swallows a rat whole, without chewing it
See the answer →Open-ended · 2mWhen a person vomits soon after a meal, food comes back up the gullet and out of the mouth
See the answer →MCQ · 2mKumar pushed a ping-pong ball into one end of a long, stretchy tube made of cloth
See the answer →Practise PSLE Science until the mistakes stop.
Three PSLE questions, free, no sign-up. You’ll see exactly where the marks went. Then 7 days of everything for S$4.99.