Knowbotic
Diversity & materialsOpen-ended · 3 marks

Mrs Lim made yoghurt in three pots of the same warm milk. She stirred a spoonful of yoghurt into each pot. Yoghurt contains tiny living bacteria.Pot P: kept at 40 °C overnightPot Q: kept in a fridge overnightPot R: boiled for 5 minutes after the yoghurt was stirred in, then kept at 40 °C overnightNext morning, pot P was thick yoghurt, but pots Q and R were still runny milk.

  1. A spoonful of yoghurt turned a whole pot of milk into yoghurt in pot P. Explain how. [1]
  2. Explain why pot R stayed runny although it was kept at 40 °C. [1]
  3. What do pots P and Q show about what the bacteria need? [1]
Need a hint?

(a) One spoonful is very little. What could the bacteria do overnight in the warm milk?

Model answer

  1. (a) A few bacteria fed and reproduced until there were very many.
  2. (b) R was as warm as P, but boiling had killed its bacteria.
  3. (c) P and Q differ only in temperature: only in the warm pot did the bacteria reproduce fast enough to change the milk.

(a) The bacteria fed on the milk and reproduced, so overnight there were enough of them to change all the milk.

(b) Boiling killed the bacteria, so there were no living bacteria to change the milk.

(c) The bacteria grow and reproduce much faster when it is warm; in the cold fridge they reproduced too slowly to change the milk overnight.

How the 3 marks are given

  • (a) States that the bacteria reproduced / increased in number (feeding on the milk) until they changed all the milk.
  • (b) States that boiling killed the bacteria, so no living bacteria were left to change the milk.
  • (c) States that the bacteria grow / reproduce faster when warm (in the cold they reproduced too slowly to change the milk overnight), since only the warm pot P changed.

One mark for each point. Keywords count: an everyday word in place of the science word can lose the mark.

The mistake this question tests

Habit

Said what happened, not why

"The yoghurt spread through the milk" misses the point. The bacteria are living: they feed and reproduce, so their numbers grow overnight. Pot R shows that dead bacteria do nothing, even when it is warm.

More PSLE Science diversity & materials questions

All free diversity & materials questions →

Practise PSLE Science until the mistakes stop.

Three PSLE questions, free, no sign-up. You’ll see exactly where the marks went. Then 7 days of everything for S$4.99.