Ali kept a potted balsam plant and his pet hamster in a room with no light for three weeks. He watered the plant every day, and he gave the hamster food and water every day. At the end, the plant had died, but the hamster was healthy. Which conclusion is correct?
- Plants need light, but the hamster does not.
- No living thing needs light, because the hamster stayed healthy.
- All living things need light, because the plant died.
- The plant died because it was not given food, like the hamster was.
Need a hint?
How does a plant get its food, and how does the hamster get its food? What does each of them need for that?
The answer, explained
- The hamster got its food from Ali, so it did not need light.
- The plant makes its own food, which needs light.
- With no light, the plant could not make food and died: plants need light.
The mistake this question tests
Concluded more than the results show
A result for one kind of living thing cannot be stretched to all living things. The hamster is given food, so it can live in the dark. The plant makes its own food and needs light to do it, so without light it could not make food and died. Plants are not fed like animals.
Wrong answers children often give:
- No living thing needs light, because the hamster stayed healthy. Concluded more than the results show
- All living things need light, because the plant died. Concluded more than the results show
- The plant died because it was not given food, like the hamster was. Photosynthesis and respiration
More PSLE Science diversity & materials questions
Jia Hui put a dry sheet of paper inside a glass bottle and closed it tightly with a cork
See the answer →Open-ended · 2mKen dropped a plastic toy brick and a rubber ball into a basin of water
See the answer →MCQ · 2mKen says: 'Every animal that lives in water breathes through gills.'
See the answer →MCQ · 2mSwimmers push earplugs into their ears to keep pool water out
See the answer →MCQ · 2mThe leaflets of a rain tree fold up every evening as it gets dark and open again in the morning
See the answer →MCQ · 2mLiving thing X has these characteristics: it reproduces by spores, it feeds on dead matter, it cannot make…
See the answer →Practise PSLE Science until the mistakes stop.
Three PSLE questions, free, no sign-up. You’ll see exactly where the marks went. Then 7 days of everything for S$4.99.