A battery lights three bulbs, X, Y and Z, joined in a way that Ravi cannot see. All three bulbs are lit. He unscrews bulb X, and bulb Y stays lit. He says: "This shows that X and Y are on separate branches, in parallel with each other."Which arrangement shows that Ravi could be wrong?
- X, Y and Z each on a separate branch
- X and Z in series on one branch, and Y alone on another branch
- Y in the main wire, then X and Z on two separate branches
- X, Y and Z all in series
Need a hint?
Ravi's result only tells you that Y still has a complete path without X. Is there more than one way for that to happen?
The answer, explained
- All in series would put Y out, so that arrangement does not fit the result.
- Separate branches for X and Y fit the result and agree with Ravi.
- Y in the main wire, with X and Z on branches, also fits, but then X and Y are not in parallel.
The mistake this question tests
Concluded more than the results show
Y stays lit as long as some complete path through Y is left. If Y is in the main wire and Z's branch is still complete, Y stays lit when X is unscrewed, yet X and Y are not on separate parallel branches. All in series does not fit the result, and the other two arrangements agree with Ravi.
Wrong answers children often give:
- X, Y and Z each on a separate branch Concluded more than the results show
- X and Z in series on one branch, and Y alone on another branch Concluded more than the results show
- X, Y and Z all in series Closed circuits, series and parallel
More PSLE Science electrical systems questions
Sam joined two identical bulbs, P and Q, in parallel to a battery, each on its own branch
See the answer →MCQ · 2mLin touched the two clips of a working circuit tester to a dry paper towel, 2 cm apart, and the bulb did not…
See the answer →Open-ended · 2mLim joined 1, 2, 3 and then 4 identical bulbs to a new battery, each bulb on its own branch, in parallel
See the answer →MCQ · 2mThe number display above a hawker stall uses seven light bars for each digit
See the answer →MCQ · 2mA door alarm uses a switch made of two thin, springy strips sealed in a glass tube, with a small gap between…
See the answer →Open-ended · 3mJia is building a bedside light with one battery, one switch, S, and three identical bulbs
See the answer →Practise PSLE Science until the mistakes stop.
Three PSLE questions, free, no sign-up. You’ll see exactly where the marks went. Then 7 days of everything for S$4.99.