Knowbotic
Matter & waterMCQ · 2 marks

Three identical thermometers hung side by side in a room at 30 °C. Thermometer P was dry. Thermometer Q had its bulb wrapped in a wet cloth. Thermometer R had its bulb wrapped in an identical wet cloth, with a fan blowing room air onto it.Which shows the most likely readings after 10 minutes?

  1. P: 30 °C, Q: 30 °C, R: 30 °C
  2. P: 30 °C, Q: 27 °C, R: 30 °C
  3. P: 30 °C, Q: 24 °C, R: 27 °C
  4. P: 30 °C, Q: 27 °C, R: 24 °C
Need a hint?

What happens to the water in each wet cloth, and where does it get the heat it needs? What does the fan change?

The answer, explained

  1. P is dry, so it reads the room temperature, 30 °C.
  2. The water in Q's cloth evaporates, taking heat from the bulb, so Q reads lower.
  3. The fan's moving air makes R's water evaporate faster, taking heat faster, so R reads lowest.
Answer (4): P: 30 °C, Q: 27 °C, R: 24 °C

The mistake this question tests

Habit

Stopped before the full cause and effect

The fan blows room air at 30 °C, but it is not the air that cools R: the fan makes the water in the cloth evaporate faster. Evaporating water takes heat from the thermometer bulb, so a wet bulb reads below room temperature, and the faster evaporation with the fan makes R read lowest.

Wrong answers children often give:

  • P: 30 °C, Q: 30 °C, R: 30 °C Heat and temperature
  • P: 30 °C, Q: 27 °C, R: 30 °C Stopped before the full cause and effect
  • P: 30 °C, Q: 24 °C, R: 27 °C Stopped before the full cause and effect

More PSLE Science matter & water questions

All free matter & water questions →

Practise PSLE Science until the mistakes stop.

Three PSLE questions, free, no sign-up. You’ll see exactly where the marks went. Then 7 days of everything for S$4.99.