Knowbotic
Matter & waterOpen-ended · 3 marks

Siti has an apple, a lime and a mango.• On a beam balance, the apple and the mango balanced each other, and the lime was lighter than either.• She held each fruit completely under the water in a brim-full container, and measured the water that overflowed: 180 cm³ for the apple, 220 cm³ for the mango and 60 cm³ for the lime.

  1. Which fruit takes up the most space? Explain how the results show this. [1]
  2. Siti says, "The apple and the mango have the same volume, because they balanced." Explain why she is wrong. [1]
  3. She cut the apple into slices and put all of them back on the balance, with nothing lost. Would the slices still balance the mango? Explain. [1]
Need a hint?

Which test measured how much space each fruit takes up, and which measured how much matter it has?

Model answer

  1. (a) The overflow equals the space each fruit takes up: the mango's 220 cm³ is largest.
  2. (b) Balancing shows equal mass, but 180 cm³ and 220 cm³ are different volumes.
  3. (c) No apple was added or lost, so the slices have the same mass and still balance.

(a) The mango. It pushed out the most water, 220 cm³, so it has the largest volume.

(b) A balance compares mass, not volume. The apple and the mango have the same mass, but they pushed out different volumes of water (180 cm³ and 220 cm³), so their volumes are different.

(c) Yes. Cutting changed only the apple's shape; nothing was added or lost, so its mass stayed the same.

How the 3 marks are given

  • (a) States the mango, because it pushed out the most water (220 cm³), so it has the largest volume.
  • (b) States that the balance shows equal mass only; the overflow results (180 cm³ and 220 cm³) show different volumes.
  • (c) States yes, because cutting changes only the shape, so the apple's mass is unchanged.

One mark for each point. Keywords count: an everyday word in place of the science word can lose the mark.

The mistake this question tests

Habit

Reading results from a graph or table

A beam balance compares mass; the water that overflows measures volume. The apple and the mango have the same mass but different volumes, so mass does not tell you volume. Cutting the apple changes its shape, not its mass.

More PSLE Science matter & water questions

All free matter & water questions →

Practise PSLE Science until the mistakes stop.

Three PSLE questions, free, no sign-up. You’ll see exactly where the marks went. Then 7 days of everything for S$4.99.