Knowbotic
Magnets & forcesMCQ · 2 marks

A sealed plastic bag holds 200 g of ice. It hangs from a spring balance, which reads 2.0 N. The bag is left hanging in a warm room until all the ice has melted and the bag has warmed to room temperature and is dry on the outside. Nothing can get into or out of the bag. What does the spring balance read now?

  1. 2.0 N, because the water in the bag has the same mass as the ice had
  2. less than 2.0 N, because water takes up less space than ice
  3. less than 2.0 N, because some of the water has evaporated
  4. more than 2.0 N, because water is heavier than ice
Need a hint?

Read the stem again: what can get into or out of the bag? Then think about what a spring balance reading depends on.

The answer, explained

  1. Melting changes ice into water: the state changes, but the amount of matter does not.
  2. The bag is sealed and dry outside, so nothing has been added or lost.
  3. Same mass, same gravitational force: the spring balance still reads 2.0 N.
Answer (1): 2.0 N, because the water in the bag has the same mass as the ice had

The mistake this question tests

Habit

Melting, evaporating, boiling, condensing

Melting changes the state of the water, not its mass. The bag is sealed, so no water escapes, even as water vapour. The same mass has the same gravitational force, so the reading stays 2.0 N.

Wrong answers children often give:

  • less than 2.0 N, because water takes up less space than ice Melting, evaporating, boiling, condensing
  • less than 2.0 N, because some of the water has evaporated Melting, evaporating, boiling, condensing
  • more than 2.0 N, because water is heavier than ice Melting, evaporating, boiling, condensing

More PSLE Science magnets & forces questions

All free magnets & forces questions →

Practise PSLE Science until the mistakes stop.

Three PSLE questions, free, no sign-up. You’ll see exactly where the marks went. Then 7 days of everything for S$4.99.