Knowbotic
Diversity & materialsOpen-ended · 3 marks

At a recycling centre, a mix of steel food cans, aluminium drink cans, glass jars and plastic bottle caps is first crushed flat. The mix then passes under a strong magnet. The items the magnet leaves behind are tipped into a tank of water: the plastic caps float, and the crushed aluminium cans and glass jars sink.

  1. Which items are picked up by the magnet? [1]
  2. Explain why the cans and jars must be crushed flat before they reach the tank of water. [1]
  3. Suggest one property that could be used to separate the aluminium from the glass at the bottom of the tank, and state how the two materials differ in it. [1]
Need a hint?

(a) Which of these metals is a magnetic material? (b) What could make an uncrushed can or jar behave differently in the water from a flat one? (c) Think about the tests you know for materials. Which would give different results for aluminium and glass?

Model answer

  1. (a) Steel is a magnetic material; aluminium, glass and plastic are not.
  2. (b) An uncrushed can or jar traps air and could float with the caps; crushed, it sinks, so the tank separates the plastic from the rest.
  3. (c) Glass lets light through and does not conduct electricity; aluminium is the opposite on both.

(a) The steel food cans.

(b) An empty can or jar that is not crushed has air trapped inside it, which could make it float with the plastic caps; crushed flat, it has no air inside and sinks, so only the plastic floats.

(c) Glass lets light through but aluminium does not; or aluminium conducts electricity but glass does not.

How the 3 marks are given

  • (a) States the steel cans (only).
  • (b) States that an uncrushed can / jar traps air that could make it float (with the plastic caps), so crushing makes it sink and keeps it apart from the plastic.
  • (c) Names a property and how they differ: glass lets light through / aluminium does not; or aluminium conducts electricity / glass does not.

One mark for each point. Keywords count: an everyday word in place of the science word can lose the mark.

The mistake this question tests

Habit

Classifying by the right characteristic

Not every metal is attracted by a magnet: steel is, but aluminium is not, so the aluminium cans stay behind with the glass and plastic. An empty can or jar that is not crushed holds air, which can make it float even though its material sinks. Being metal or being hard does not separate aluminium from glass; transparency or conducting electricity does.

More PSLE Science diversity & materials questions

All free diversity & materials questions →

Practise PSLE Science until the mistakes stop.

Three PSLE questions, free, no sign-up. You’ll see exactly where the marks went. Then 7 days of everything for S$4.99.