Ravi's hypothesis is: Listening to fast music raises a person's heart rate while sitting still. He tests it on his classmates.
- Ravi measured each classmate's heart rate while they sat still and listened to fast music. Explain why these results alone cannot test his hypothesis. [1]
- Each classmate walked quickly to Ravi's room from the field just before being tested. Explain why this could spoil his results. [1]
- State one other thing he should keep the same for every classmate. [1]
Need a hint?
(a) How would Ravi know the heart rate had been raised? Raised compared with what?
Model answer
- (a) Measure each classmate with and without fast music, then compare.
- (b) Walking quickly raises the heart rate for some minutes.
- (c) Keep everything except the music the same.
(a) There is nothing to compare with: he must also measure each classmate's heart rate while sitting still without the music (or with slow music), to see whether the fast music raised it.
(b) Walking quickly raises the heart rate, and it stays raised for some minutes, so a high reading might be caused by the walk, not the music (they should sit still for a few minutes first).
(c) The same loudness of music (or the same listening time, the same room, the same way of measuring the heart rate).
How the 3 marks are given
- (a) States that he needs to compare with each classmate's heart rate without the fast music (no music / slow music).
- (b) States that walking raises the heart rate, so a high reading may be due to the walk and not the music.
- (c) States one: same loudness, same listening time, same room / temperature, same way or length of time of measuring, sitting still.
One mark for each point. Keywords count: an everyday word in place of the science word can lose the mark.
The mistake this question tests
Fair test: what changes, what stays the same
A hypothesis about music raising the heart rate needs a comparison: the same people sitting still without fast music. Exercise also raises the heart rate, so classmates must be fully rested before each count, or the walk, not the music, could cause a high reading.
More PSLE Science human systems questions
Ravi wanted to find out whether the number of laps he swims affects his heart rate
See the answer →MCQ · 2mMira's hypothesis is: The smaller the pieces of food, the faster they are digested
See the answer →MCQ · 2mWei claims: "Food is digested only in the stomach." Which observation shows that his claim is wrong?
See the answer →MCQ · 2mA python swallows a rat whole, without chewing it
See the answer →Open-ended · 2mWhen a person vomits soon after a meal, food comes back up the gullet and out of the mouth
See the answer →MCQ · 2mKumar pushed a ping-pong ball into one end of a long, stretchy tube made of cloth
See the answer →Practise PSLE Science until the mistakes stop.
Three PSLE questions, free, no sign-up. You’ll see exactly where the marks went. Then 7 days of everything for S$4.99.