Some pupils wanted to find out whether it is cooler under a black umbrella or a white umbrella in the sun. At 12 noon, Ali held a thermometer under the black umbrella for 3 minutes: it read 33 °C. At 12.10 pm, he held the same thermometer under the white umbrella for 3 minutes: it read 34 °C. The umbrellas were the same size and material, apart from their colour.
- Give one reason why the pupils cannot be sure, from these two readings, which umbrella keeps a person cooler. [1]
- Suggest two changes to the way they take the readings that would make their results more reliable. [1]
Need a hint?
(a) Compare how and when the two readings were taken.
Model answer
- (a) One reading each, 10 minutes apart, only 1 °C different.
- (b) Read both at the same time with two identical thermometers.
- (b) Repeat several times and compare the averages.
(a) There was only one reading under each umbrella and the difference is only 1 °C; the readings were also taken 10 minutes apart, so the air temperature or sunshine may have changed in between.
(b) Read two identical thermometers under both umbrellas at the same time; repeat the readings several times (or on several days) and compare the averages.
How the 2 marks are given
- (a) Gives one valid reason: only one reading each / the 1 °C difference is small / the readings were taken at different times, so the conditions may have changed.
- (b) Gives two of: read under both umbrellas at the same time (two identical thermometers); repeat several times and compare averages; hold the thermometer at the same height under each umbrella.
One mark for each point. Keywords count: an everyday word in place of the science word can lose the mark.
The mistake this question tests
Reading results from a graph or table
"Do it again" alone is not enough. The two readings were taken 10 minutes apart, so the sun and the air could have changed in between, and with one reading each a 1 °C difference may be chance. Read both at the same time, and repeat.
More PSLE Science light & heat questions
Jun wants to know which of two spots in his garden, by the fence or by the pond, gets more light for a solar…
See the answer →MCQ · 2mBeaker X held 200 ml of water at 10 °C and beaker Y held 200 ml of water at 40 °C
See the answer →MCQ · 2mSome steel pots have a layer of copper on the outside of the base
See the answer →MCQ · 2mAt night, Lina cycles along a dark country road with no street lamps
See the answer →Open-ended · 4mAt a night football match, the field is lit by four tall floodlights, one at each corner of the field, and…
See the answer →MCQ · 2mRavi kept a laboratory thermometer in a fridge at 5 °C
See the answer →Practise PSLE Science until the mistakes stop.
Three PSLE questions, free, no sign-up. You’ll see exactly where the marks went. Then 7 days of everything for S$4.99.