Knowbotic
Magnets & forcesMCQ · 2 marks

A pot of soil with a fern hangs from a hook by a spring. The spring is not damaged. Mr Lee watered the pot well on Monday and then gave it no more water. Nothing else was added to or taken from the pot. Each day the spring was a little shorter than the day before.Which best explains why the spring became shorter?

  1. The gravitational force on the pot became weaker each day, though its mass stayed the same.
  2. Water was lost from the soil and the plant, so the pot's mass, and the gravitational force on it, became smaller.
  3. The fern grew bigger, so the pot pulled less on the spring.
  4. The spring was stretched too far on Monday, so it could not go back to its original length.
Need a hint?

Where could some of Monday's water have gone, and what would that do to the pot's mass?

The answer, explained

  1. Water is lost from the soil and the leaves into the air, and none is added.
  2. So the pot's mass, and the gravitational force on it, get smaller each day.
  3. A smaller pull stretches the spring less, so it becomes shorter.
Answer (2): Water was lost from the soil and the plant, so the pot's mass, and the gravitational force on it, became smaller.

The mistake this question tests

Habit

Stopped before the full cause and effect

Water evaporates from the soil and is lost from the fern's leaves, so the pot has less mass. Less mass means a smaller gravitational force, so the spring is stretched less. A spring stretched too far would stay longer, not get shorter, and the pull does not weaken while the mass stays the same.

Wrong answers children often give:

  • The gravitational force on the pot became weaker each day, though its mass stayed the same. Friction, gravity and springs
  • The fern grew bigger, so the pot pulled less on the spring. Stopped before the full cause and effect
  • The spring was stretched too far on Monday, so it could not go back to its original length. Friction, gravity and springs

More PSLE Science magnets & forces questions

All free magnets & forces questions →

Practise PSLE Science until the mistakes stop.

Three PSLE questions, free, no sign-up. You’ll see exactly where the marks went. Then 7 days of everything for S$4.99.