Knowbotic
Matter & waterMCQ · 2 marks

Mdm Lee dries anchovies (ikan bilis) in the sun. After washing them, she drains them so no water drips from them. She spreads one batch in a single layer on a wire-mesh rack raised above the ground, and an equal batch in a single layer on a solid plastic tray beside it. The batch on the mesh rack dries faster.Which is the best explanation?

  1. On the mesh, air reaches the underside of the fish too, so more of their wet surface is exposed and the water evaporates faster.
  2. The mesh rack makes the water in the fish boil sooner, because it is raised up.
  3. The fish on the mesh rack hold less water, because the mesh squeezes the water out.
  4. No water at all evaporates from the fish on the tray, because the tray stops air reaching them.
Need a hint?

Where is the wet surface of each fish touching the air on the rack, and on the tray?

The answer, explained

  1. Water evaporates from the wet surface that is exposed to the air.
  2. On the tray only the top of each fish is exposed; on the mesh both sides are.
  3. Larger exposed surface area, so faster evaporation on the mesh.
Answer (1): On the mesh, air reaches the underside of the fish too, so more of their wet surface is exposed and the water evaporates faster.

The mistake this question tests

Habit

Said what happened, not why

The water does not boil: it evaporates at the surface that is open to the air. On the tray, the underside of each fish lies against the plastic, so only the top is exposed. On the mesh, air reaches the top and the underside, so the exposed surface area is larger and the water evaporates faster.

Wrong answers children often give:

  • The mesh rack makes the water in the fish boil sooner, because it is raised up. Melting, evaporating, boiling, condensing
  • The fish on the mesh rack hold less water, because the mesh squeezes the water out. Said what happened, not why
  • No water at all evaporates from the fish on the tray, because the tray stops air reaching them. Said what happened, not why

More PSLE Science matter & water questions

All free matter & water questions →

Practise PSLE Science until the mistakes stop.

Three PSLE questions, free, no sign-up. You’ll see exactly where the marks went. Then 7 days of everything for S$4.99.