Ken filled two identical clear plastic bags to the top with the same pond water and tied them shut so that no air was inside. Bag 1 had a water plant in it and bag 2 had no plant. He hung both bags in the same sunny spot. After 4 hours, a large bubble of gas had collected at the top of bag 1. Bag 2 had no bubble.What does comparing the two bags show?
- The plant gives out the gas only when it is in light.
- The gas in bag 1 was carbon dioxide that the plant gave out as it respired.
- The gas came from the plant, not from the pond water being warmed by the sun.
- Water in sunlight evaporates and collects as a bubble of gas.
Need a hint?
What is the only difference between the two bags? What did both bags have the same?
The answer, explained
- The bags differ in one thing only: the plant.
- Both were warmed by the same sunlight, but only bag 1 formed a bubble.
- So the gas came from the plant (the oxygen it gave out as it photosynthesised), not from the water.
The mistake this question tests
Fair test: what changes, what stays the same
Both bags were in the same sunlight, so the comparison cannot show anything about light: to test that, one bag with a plant would have to be kept in the dark. The bags differ only in the plant, and only the bag with the plant formed a bubble, so the gas came from the plant, not from the warmed water. In light, a water plant photosynthesises and gives out oxygen, more than the carbon dioxide it gives out as it respires.
Wrong answers children often give:
- The plant gives out the gas only when it is in light. Fair test: what changes, what stays the same
- The gas in bag 1 was carbon dioxide that the plant gave out as it respired. Photosynthesis and respiration
- Water in sunlight evaporates and collects as a bubble of gas. Photosynthesis and respiration
More PSLE Science photosynthesis & energy questions
Wei Ling wanted to find out how the number of leaves on a plant affects how fast it photosynthesises
See the answer →MCQ · 2mSiti wants to find out whether the number of times she winds the key of a wind-up toy affects how far the toy…
See the answer →MCQ · 2mImagine that all the green plants and algae on Earth stopped photosynthesising
See the answer →MCQ · 2mWhich of these have both kinetic energy and gravitational potential energy?
See the answer →Open-ended · 3mOn a steep hill railway, two cars are joined by one long cable that passes round a wheel at the top, so that…
See the answer →Open-ended · 2mSome large seaweeds are fixed to rocks on the sea floor by a root-like holdfast
See the answer →Practise PSLE Science until the mistakes stop.
Three PSLE questions, free, no sign-up. You’ll see exactly where the marks went. Then 7 days of everything for S$4.99.