Knowbotic
Photosynthesis & energyMCQ · 2 marks

Ken filled two identical clear plastic bags to the top with the same pond water and tied them shut so that no air was inside. Bag 1 had a water plant in it and bag 2 had no plant. He hung both bags in the same sunny spot. After 4 hours, a large bubble of gas had collected at the top of bag 1. Bag 2 had no bubble.What does comparing the two bags show?

  1. The plant gives out the gas only when it is in light.
  2. The gas in bag 1 was carbon dioxide that the plant gave out as it respired.
  3. The gas came from the plant, not from the pond water being warmed by the sun.
  4. Water in sunlight evaporates and collects as a bubble of gas.
Need a hint?

What is the only difference between the two bags? What did both bags have the same?

The answer, explained

  1. The bags differ in one thing only: the plant.
  2. Both were warmed by the same sunlight, but only bag 1 formed a bubble.
  3. So the gas came from the plant (the oxygen it gave out as it photosynthesised), not from the water.
Answer (3): The gas came from the plant, not from the pond water being warmed by the sun.

The mistake this question tests

Habit

Fair test: what changes, what stays the same

Both bags were in the same sunlight, so the comparison cannot show anything about light: to test that, one bag with a plant would have to be kept in the dark. The bags differ only in the plant, and only the bag with the plant formed a bubble, so the gas came from the plant, not from the warmed water. In light, a water plant photosynthesises and gives out oxygen, more than the carbon dioxide it gives out as it respires.

Wrong answers children often give:

  • The plant gives out the gas only when it is in light. Fair test: what changes, what stays the same
  • The gas in bag 1 was carbon dioxide that the plant gave out as it respired. Photosynthesis and respiration
  • Water in sunlight evaporates and collects as a bubble of gas. Photosynthesis and respiration

More PSLE Science photosynthesis & energy questions

All free photosynthesis & energy questions →

Practise PSLE Science until the mistakes stop.

Three PSLE questions, free, no sign-up. You’ll see exactly where the marks went. Then 7 days of everything for S$4.99.