Knowbotic
Magnets & forcesMCQ · 2 marks

Kai tested two magnets: a large, thin, bendy magnetic sheet cut from an old car sign, and a small, thick button magnet. He lowered each onto a pile of identical steel washers and lifted it. The sheet lifted 3 washers; the button magnet lifted 11. He repeated the test three times and got the same results.Which conclusion is supported by his results?

  1. Smaller magnets are always stronger than bigger magnets.
  2. The sheet is not a magnet, because it lifted only 3 washers.
  3. The button magnet's magnetic force on the washers is stronger than the sheet's.
  4. The button magnet is stronger because it is heavier than the sheet.
Need a hint?

Kai tested only two magnets. Can two magnets tell you a rule about all magnets?

The answer, explained

  1. The button magnet lifted more identical washers every time.
  2. So, in this test, its magnetic force was stronger than the sheet's.
  3. The size of a magnet does not decide its strength, and two magnets cannot give a rule for all magnets.
Answer (3): The button magnet's magnetic force on the washers is stronger than the sheet's.

The mistake this question tests

Habit

Concluded more than the results show

Two magnets cannot show a rule for all magnets, and Kai did not measure their masses, so the data say nothing about weight. The sheet did lift washers, so it is a magnet. The results show only that the button magnet attracted the washers more strongly.

Wrong answers children often give:

  • Smaller magnets are always stronger than bigger magnets. Concluded more than the results show
  • The sheet is not a magnet, because it lifted only 3 washers. Magnets: attract, repel, poles
  • The button magnet is stronger because it is heavier than the sheet. Concluded more than the results show

More PSLE Science magnets & forces questions

All free magnets & forces questions →

Practise PSLE Science until the mistakes stop.

Three PSLE questions, free, no sign-up. You’ll see exactly where the marks went. Then 7 days of everything for S$4.99.