Kai tested two magnets: a large, thin, bendy magnetic sheet cut from an old car sign, and a small, thick button magnet. He lowered each onto a pile of identical steel washers and lifted it. The sheet lifted 3 washers; the button magnet lifted 11. He repeated the test three times and got the same results.Which conclusion is supported by his results?
- Smaller magnets are always stronger than bigger magnets.
- The sheet is not a magnet, because it lifted only 3 washers.
- The button magnet's magnetic force on the washers is stronger than the sheet's.
- The button magnet is stronger because it is heavier than the sheet.
Need a hint?
Kai tested only two magnets. Can two magnets tell you a rule about all magnets?
The answer, explained
- The button magnet lifted more identical washers every time.
- So, in this test, its magnetic force was stronger than the sheet's.
- The size of a magnet does not decide its strength, and two magnets cannot give a rule for all magnets.
The mistake this question tests
Concluded more than the results show
Two magnets cannot show a rule for all magnets, and Kai did not measure their masses, so the data say nothing about weight. The sheet did lift washers, so it is a magnet. The results show only that the button magnet attracted the washers more strongly.
Wrong answers children often give:
- Smaller magnets are always stronger than bigger magnets. Concluded more than the results show
- The sheet is not a magnet, because it lifted only 3 washers. Magnets: attract, repel, poles
- The button magnet is stronger because it is heavier than the sheet. Concluded more than the results show
More PSLE Science magnets & forces questions
A carpark cleaner pushes a magnetic sweeper: a long, strong magnet on wheels, held 3 cm above the ground
See the answer →MCQ · 2mKen's hanging scale has a spring with a pointer beside marks in grams, 1 cm apart
See the answer →MCQ · 2mImagine a flat road with no friction at all
See the answer →MCQ · 2mLina slides a bar magnet slowly along a smooth wooden track towards a steel trolley
See the answer →MCQ · 2mA spring hangs from a hook
See the answer →Open-ended · 3mA hotplate stirrer in a laboratory has a magnet under its flat top, which a motor turns round and round
See the answer →Practise PSLE Science until the mistakes stop.
Three PSLE questions, free, no sign-up. You’ll see exactly where the marks went. Then 7 days of everything for S$4.99.