Jia wanted to find out whether a copper cup or a plastic cup keeps a cold drink cold for longer. She poured 200 ml of juice at 5 °C into each cup, in a room at 30 °C. The copper cup was thin and had a plastic lid. The plastic cup was thick and had no lid. After 30 minutes, the juice in the copper cup was at 18 °C and the juice in the plastic cup was at 21 °C. Jia concluded that copper keeps drinks cold better than plastic.
- State one difference between the two cups, other than their material, that made the test unfair. [1]
- Explain why Jia's conclusion cannot be trusted. [1]
- She repeated the test fairly, with cups of the same size and thickness and no lids. Predict which cup kept the juice colder, and explain. [1]
Need a hint?
(b) If the copper cup kept its juice colder, what else about that cup might have caused it?
Model answer
- (a) The cups differed in lid and in thickness as well as material.
- (b) With several variables changed, Jia cannot tell which one caused the difference.
- (c) In a fair test, plastic, the poorer conductor of heat, lets heat into the juice more slowly.
(a) The copper cup had a lid but the plastic cup did not (or: the cups were of different thickness).
(b) More than one thing was different between the cups, so the difference in temperature might have been caused by the lid or the thickness, not by the material.
(c) The plastic cup. Plastic is a poorer conductor of heat than copper, so heat from the warm room flows into the juice more slowly.
How the 3 marks are given
- (a) States the lid (one cup had a lid, the other did not) / the thickness of the cups was different.
- (b) States that more than one variable was changed, so the result could be due to the lid / thickness instead of the material.
- (c) Names the plastic cup, because plastic is a poorer heat conductor, so heat from the room enters the juice more slowly.
One mark for each point. Keywords count: an everyday word in place of the science word can lose the mark.
The mistake this question tests
Fair test: what changes, what stays the same
For (b), many pupils just write "it is not a fair test". Explain why that matters: because the lid and the thickness were also different, the colder juice in the copper cup could be due to the lid, not the copper. For (c), the fair test favours plastic, the poorer conductor of heat.
More PSLE Science light & heat questions
Zul wanted to find out whether the size of an object affects the size of its shadow
See the answer →MCQ · 2mPriya wants to find out whether a knitted cover keeps tea in a teapot hot for longer
See the answer →MCQ · 2mSome steel pots have a layer of copper on the outside of the base
See the answer →MCQ · 2mAt night, Lina cycles along a dark country road with no street lamps
See the answer →Open-ended · 4mAt a night football match, the field is lit by four tall floodlights, one at each corner of the field, and…
See the answer →MCQ · 2mRavi kept a laboratory thermometer in a fridge at 5 °C
See the answer →Practise PSLE Science until the mistakes stop.
Three PSLE questions, free, no sign-up. You’ll see exactly where the marks went. Then 7 days of everything for S$4.99.