Knowbotic
Electrical systemsOpen-ended · 3 marks

A food stall's plate warmer has six heating wires, W1 to W6, fixed under a glass plate. One end of every wire is joined to a copper bar along the left edge of the plate, and the other end to a copper bar along the right edge. The two bars are joined to a battery through a switch. When the switch is closed, current flows through the wires, which get hot and warm the plate.

  1. One day, the part of the plate above W2 stays cold, but the rest of the plate warms up as usual. Explain how this shows that the wires are joined in parallel. [1]
  2. Suggest what is wrong with W2. [1]
  3. The owner wants a steel plate instead of the glass one, with the wires and bars touching it. Explain why the warmer would then not work. [1]
Need a hint?

(a) If all six wires were on one path, what would a break in W2 do to the others?

Model answer

  1. (a) In series, one broken wire would stop all six; here five still got hot, so they are in parallel.
  2. (b) No current flows through W2, so its path has a gap: W2 is broken or loose.
  3. (c) A steel plate would join the bars with no heating wire in the way, so the current would go round the wires.

(a) W1 and W3 to W6 still got hot while no current flowed through W2. If the wires were in series, a break in W2 would leave a gap in the only path and none of them would get hot. So each wire must be on its own separate path between the bars, in parallel.

(b) W2 is broken somewhere along its length (or has come loose from a bar), so there is a gap in W2's path and no current flows through it.

(c) Steel conducts electricity. Touching both bars, it would be a path from one bar to the other with no heating wire in it, so the current would flow through the steel instead of through the wires, and the wires would not get hot.

How the 3 marks are given

  • (a) States the other wires still got hot when W2 did not, which would not happen in series, so each wire has its own path (parallel).
  • (b) States W2 is broken / loose at a bar, leaving a gap in its path.
  • (c) States steel conducts, so the current would flow through the plate from bar to bar instead of through the wires (or: anyone touching the plate could get a shock).

One mark for each point. Keywords count: an everyday word in place of the science word can lose the mark.

The mistake this question tests

Habit

Said what happened, not why

For (a), a cold patch over one wire does not mean the whole warmer has failed: the other wires were still closed circuits, which can only happen if each wire has its own path, in parallel. For (c), steel is a conductor: it would join the two bars directly, so the current would bypass the heating wires.

More PSLE Science electrical systems questions

All free electrical systems questions →

Practise PSLE Science until the mistakes stop.

Three PSLE questions, free, no sign-up. You’ll see exactly where the marks went. Then 7 days of everything for S$4.99.