Knowbotic
Living things & environmentOpen-ended · 3 marks

In a cold country, a lake freezes over in winter. The ice is clear, but sometimes thick snow lies on top of it for weeks. The ice stops air from the atmosphere dissolving into the water. Water plants and fish live in the lake under the ice.In a winter with thick snow on the ice for many weeks, many fish died. In a winter with clear ice and no snow, few fish died.

  1. Explain why the amount of oxygen in the water fell when thick snow lay on the ice. [2]
  2. People sometimes clear the snow off parts of the ice. Explain how this helps the fish. [1]
Need a hint?

(a) Compare a winter of clear ice with a winter of thick snow on top. What would reach the water plants underneath in each, and what would that change?

Model answer

  1. (a) Snow stops light reaching the water, so the plants stop photosynthesising and stop giving out oxygen.
  2. All living things in the lake keep taking in oxygen, and the ice stops oxygen dissolving from the air.
  3. So the oxygen is used up and fish die.
  4. (b) With the snow cleared, light reaches the plants, which give out oxygen again.

(a) The snow blocks light, so the water plants cannot photosynthesise and do not give out oxygen. The fish and plants keep taking in oxygen for respiration, and the ice stops new oxygen dissolving from the air, so the oxygen is used up.

(b) More light reaches the plants, so they photosynthesise and give out oxygen for the fish.

How the 3 marks are given

  • (a) States that snow blocks light, so the water plants cannot photosynthesise / give out oxygen.
  • (a) States that the fish (and plants) keep using oxygen in respiration and no oxygen can enter from the air, so it is used up.
  • (b) States that light can reach the plants again so they photosynthesise and give out oxygen for the fish.

One mark for each point. Keywords count: an everyday word in place of the science word can lose the mark.

The mistake this question tests

Habit

Photosynthesis and respiration

"The water is too cold" does not explain it: the ice was cold in both winters. The difference is light: under snow the plants cannot photosynthesise, so no oxygen is added while living things keep using it.

More PSLE Science living things & environment questions

All free living things & environment questions →

Practise PSLE Science until the mistakes stop.

Three PSLE questions, free, no sign-up. You’ll see exactly where the marks went. Then 7 days of everything for S$4.99.