Knowbotic
Diversity & materialsOpen-ended · 3 marks

Before a storm, sandbags are piled at a doorway to keep flood water out. Mr Lee had two kinds of sack of the same size: sacks made of jute, a fibre that comes from a plant, and sacks made of plastic. He filled each sack with 15 kg of sand. After the storm, water had seeped through the pile of jute sacks, but not through the pile of plastic sacks. Jute sacks left outside in the damp became weak and rotted within a few months; the plastic sacks did not.

  1. Which property must both kinds of sack have so that they can be lifted with 15 kg of sand inside? [1]
  2. Which property of the plastic sacks made them better at keeping the water out? [1]
  3. Suggest why the jute sacks rotted but the plastic sacks did not. [1]
Need a hint?

(c) Read where jute comes from. What happens to things that come from plants and animals when they are left in damp places?

Model answer

  1. (a) A sack holding 15 kg of sand must not tear: strong.
  2. (b) Water did not pass through the plastic: waterproof.
  3. (c) Fungi and bacteria feed on plant material such as jute in the damp, breaking it down.

(a) They must be strong.

(b) Plastic is waterproof.

(c) Jute comes from a plant, so decomposers such as fungi and bacteria can feed on it and break it down in damp conditions; they cannot feed on the plastic.

How the 3 marks are given

  • (a) States strong.
  • (b) States waterproof (does not let water through).
  • (c) States that jute is from a plant, so fungi / bacteria (decomposers) feed on it and break it down, but not plastic.

One mark for each point. Keywords count: an everyday word in place of the science word can lose the mark.

The mistake this question tests

Habit

Stopped before the full cause and effect

Rotting is not caused by the water alone: it is caused by decomposers such as fungi and bacteria feeding on the material. Jute comes from a plant, so it is food for them; plastic is not. The plastic is also waterproof, which is why water did not seep through.

More PSLE Science diversity & materials questions

All free diversity & materials questions →

Practise PSLE Science until the mistakes stop.

Three PSLE questions, free, no sign-up. You’ll see exactly where the marks went. Then 7 days of everything for S$4.99.