Knowbotic
Synthesis & transformationSynthesis · 2 marks

Join or change the sentence(s) into one sentence that uses the word(s) in bold and keeps the same meaning.

The neighbours put out the small fire in the rubbish chute. Then the firefighters arrived.

By the time ...

Need a hint?

Which action happened earlier? What tense shows an action finished before another past one?

Model answer

  1. "By the time" goes with the later action: the firefighters arrived.
  2. The earlier action, putting out the fire, takes the past perfect: had put out.
  3. "already" may be added; it keeps the meaning.
Answer: By the time the firefighters arrived, the neighbours had put out the small fire in the rubbish chute.

Also accepted: By the time the firefighters arrived the neighbours had put out the small fire in the rubbish chute.; By the time the firefighters arrived, the neighbours had already put out the small fire in the rubbish chute.; By the time the firefighters arrived the neighbours had already put out the small fire in the rubbish chute.

What the marker looks for

  • Uses "By the time the firefighters arrived", with the past perfect ("had put out") for the earlier action.
  • Keeps the meaning (the neighbours put out the fire before the firefighters arrived) in one correct sentence.

The mistake this question tests

Habit

Keeping the tense

The fire was out before the firefighters came, so the earlier action needs had put out: "the neighbours put out" loses that order.

More PSLE English synthesis & transformation questions

All free synthesis & transformation questions →

Practise PSLE English until the mistakes stop.

Three PSLE questions, free, no sign-up. You’ll see exactly where the marks went. Then 7 days of everything for S$4.99.